Tuesday, February 27, 2007

A Shattered Glass, Half Full

Many parts of Iraq are stable now. But of course what we see on television is the one bombing a day that discourages everybody.

Laura Bush 2/26/07


And so in early 1967, Joe McGinniss, then just a young reporter for the Philadelphia Inquirer, would spend a day traveling with Westmoreland to the coastal town of Phan Thiet. There a young American officer startled McGinniss by giving an extraordinarily candid briefing on how bad the situation was, how incompetent the ARVN was. Westmoreland had demanded the briefing and the young American had been uneasy about giving it, apologizing for being so frank with a reporter present, but finally it had come pouring out: the ARVN soldiers were cowards, they refused to fight, they abused the population, in their most recent battle they had all fled, all but one man. That one man had stood and fought and almost single-handedly staved off a Vietcong attack. When the officer had finished his briefing, still apologizing for being so candid, Westmoreland turned to McGinniss and said, "Now you see how distorted the press image of this war is. This is a perfect example -- a great act of bravery and not a single mention of it in the New York Times."

David Halberstam, The Best and the Brightest, pg. 562

14 Comments:

Anonymous Kilfarsnar said...

That quote is priceless! The scene from Full Metal Jacket when Joker is a young reporter getting a taste of press "coverage" comes to mind. It also reminds me that perspective is everything.

2/27/2007 10:21 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have been re-reading Best and Brightest (the first time was over 20 years ago) prompted in part by your quotes. It is indeed astonishing how much of what is written there could be written again about current events with little change. As a nation we seem to be incapable of learning from our past mistakes.

2/27/2007 11:27 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

In November 2006, according to the Center for American Progress, there were 185 attacks/day in Iraq. You'd think a librarian could avoid being wrong by two orders of magnitude.

2/27/2007 1:23 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Another book about Vietnam that shows the eerie parallels between now and then is "In Retrospect" by Robert S. McNamara. It was written in the mid-1990s, but the history and the lessons he draws from that history are in some ways completely applicable to Iraq today.

2/27/2007 1:27 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

When have facts ever mattered to any member of this administration!

Lie, lie, smear and smear and smear.

That is the christian, republican patriatic way.
Oh, and by the way use the constitution for toilet paper, as it is an unamerican and unpatriatic document.

2/27/2007 1:27 PM  
Blogger Lifetime Fiscal Conservative said...

Why do they let that woman speak on anything real? Let her do her feel-good talks and have her avoid things that are important. Kind of like her husband.

She and George are like that very, very old couple living on your block. What comes out of their mouths and reality don't always have a lot to do with each other.

2/27/2007 1:48 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Though if Halberstam were writing about Iraq, he'd call it The Worst and the Stupidest

2/28/2007 3:30 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Heck, Only one attack a day Laura? Then it would be plenty safe for your daughters to go over and do truck driving or something.

2/28/2007 3:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's aggravating to see willful ignorance of the administration and ever more aggravating to see it in a large minority of Americans.

2/28/2007 4:50 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The reporter should have asked:

"Mrs. Bush, can you tell us how many bombs explode on average each day in Iraq?"

2/28/2007 10:50 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The reporter should have asked:

"Mrs. Bush, can you tell us how many bombs explode on average each day in Iraq?"

2/28/2007 10:50 PM  
Blogger Deep Thapa said...

bingo casinos bingo casinos hoodia prices hoodia prices online credit history internet credit reports credit reports online bingo websites
bingo bingo online yahoo bingo internet bingo free online bingo bingo game free online bingo game bingo supply bingo card play bingo online online bingo game three eyed bingo leisure bingo bingo hotspot play free bingo online hey bingo delta bingo free printable baby shower bingo game online bingo uk bingo par php réalisé script online bingo hall bingo self storage free bingo for money pogo bingo bingo bingomega online bingo bugle amaze bingo it main street will free online bingo tournament gala bingo yahoo bingo game bingo gala 100 deposit bonus bingo cost zero bingo mania free printable baby bingo game free bingo bee bingo free bingo easter i play bingo bingo game on the web baby shower bingo free blank bingo card bingo site web bingo gone bingo game for kid yahoo free bingo make bingo card beach blanket bingo free printable bingo card play kid bingo bingo ball play bingo free bingo card maker best online bingo on line bingo bingo card for kid bingo michigan supply potawatomi bingo free bingo game on yahoo 100 bingo bonus deposit empire math bingo game play bingo win money free slingo.com bingo game free chat bingo printable bingo game entertainment bingo play uk bingo free bingo game australia free kid bingo game online san manuel indian bingo and casino bingo online pay pal place to play bingo uk bingo bingo casino play game online free bingo palace astro bingo free canada bingo free baby bingo blank bingo card template play bingo for money online play live bingo lycos free bingo no deposit bingo free bingo bonus online bingo bonus yahoo speedy bingo new online bingo site large print bingo card potawatomi bingo casino sun bingo bingo kid online bingo download quick free bingo room bingo free online poker bingo world travel bingo card free internet bingo bingo card maker choctaw bingo pogo ez win free bingo yahoo online bingo

4/20/2007 9:59 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Web Credit Report
Credit Report
Credit Reports
Credit Report Online
Credit Reports Onlin
Credit Score
Free Credit Report
Free Credit Reports
Online Credit Report
Online Credit Reports
Credit History Online
Internet Credit Report
Internet Credit Reports
Online Credit history
Web Credit Report
Check Credit
Credit Check
Free Credit score
Instant Credit Report
online Credit check
Check Credit history
Free Credit history
Get Credit Report
Credit Check online
All Credit Reports
Consumer Credit Report
Credit Bureau Report
Credit Rating
Credit Repair
Credit Report score
Credit Reporting
Full Credit Report
Check Credit Rating
3 Credit Reports
Credit History
Equifax Credit Report
Experian Credit Report
Fix Credit Report
Free Credit Reporting
Instant Credit Report Online
Trans union Credit Report

8/30/2007 5:06 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I would like to more know about it. asthma Read a useful article about tramadol tramadol

1/12/2012 6:59 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home